Joseph Cates’ Who
Killed Teddy Bear is an unexpectedly haunting oddity, a rare mix of trashiness
and delicacy, strangely dignified in its manipulativeness. A brief synopsis
more easily evokes the trashy aspect: a nightclub worker, Norah, starts to
receive vaguely threatening phone calls, a chance event bringing her to the
attention of a police detective, Madden, who oscillates between rumpled charm
and a seeming unnatural interest in, if not affinity for, such aberrant behaviour
(eventually attributed to his wife having been murdered); the threat escalates
in familiar genre fashion, right up to the killing of a co-worker mistaken for Norah
after borrowing her coat. The film is documentary-like in its surveying of New
York’s seamier side, providing loving pans over long rows of nudist magazines, “dirty”
books, porn theatre marquees and the like; as if to illustrate its underlying duality
though, there’s an extended, equally fascinated sequence following Norah
through the theatre district, taking in marquees and posters for the likes of Any
Wednesday and Golden Boy. As Norah, Juliet Prowse radiates crisp
intelligence and engagement; the frank presentation of her character contrasts
with that of the perpetrator, Lawrence (Sal Mineo), often photographed
half-naked and in extreme close-up, the imagery both sensual and aberrant. The
theme of damage and danger runs through Lawrence’s younger sister, her
development hampered by a childhood accident, Lawrence seeking to suppress her
sexual identity even as he can barely control the expression of his own; Norah’s
employer (Elaine Stritch!), whose comforting of Norah suddenly evolves into an
attempt at seduction; the deaf nightclub bouncer, injured early on in an
unrelated confrontation: even in its more straightforward moments, in its
staging of the activity on the nightclub dance floor for instance, the film
often feels oddly compulsive or desperate. The ending is again broadly
unsurprising in narrative terms, but feels as pathetic and forlorn as it does
cathartic.