I’ve rewatched Shoot the Moon, Alan
Parker’s study of turbulent divorce, more times over the years than were really
warranted, in part because of Albert Finney and Diane Keaton, but also because
of a nagging sense that a film of such sporadic impact couldn’t possibly
disappoint as much as a whole. Well, one never learns, my most recent viewing
revealed it to be as superficially gripping as ever, and no more coherent
overall. It’s not to the benefit of Parker’s film that Cassavetes’ Woman
Under the Influence comes to mind as a reference point, in the shared sense
of marriage as a messy dance, the rules unknowable except to the participants
and in any case always shifting: it’s best illustrated in Shoot the Moon in a
post-separation restaurant scene, the two arriving and intending to eat
separately, then sharing a table but soon yelling abuse at each other, drawing
in and then uniting against another couple who just want to eat in peace, delighted
with themselves as they retake their seats, ordering a ridiculous volume of
food and booze and later predictably ending up in bed together. It’s superficially
spellbinding, but like much else in the film, the behavioral whiplashing feels
arbitrary, self-contained, inadequately rooted in character. In extreme
contrast to the blue-collar specificity of Nick in the Cassavetes film, Finney’s
George Dunlap is a successful writer of the most generic kind imaginable; Keaton’s
Faith seems to have no career, no friends, no identity other than as a wife and
mother (these could of course be deliberate elements of a pointed commentary,
but seem here like mere directorial indifference). The boisterous four-child
household is energetically evoked, but the kids likewise are a largely
amorphous mass; George and Faith find new partners, each relationship depicted
in anodyne, unconvincing terms; one could go on. And yet, and yet, Parker’s
bullish gusto holds one’s attention, even if one at times feels vaguely pranked
(for instance, through the almost touchingly shameless references to some of
his other films); I wouldn’t entirely rule out yet another disappointing future
viewing.
